Title too long | General - All in One SEO Pack Pro Forum | Support | Semper Plugins

I KNOW this has to be simple but I am simply not seeing it. 

My title for every page and post grabs the site identity and appends it to the end of every page. Here is a couple of examples

(TITLE) Affordable apartments for nightly rent on Indian Point | (SITE IDENTITY) Branson Resorts and Condos For Nightly Rent On Indian Point

(TITLE) Mid floor condo for rent on Indian Point with a large table | (SITE IDENTITY)  Branson Resorts and Condos For Nightly Rent On Indian Point

Everything keeps appending the Branson Resorts and Condos For Nightly Rent On Indian Point      

to the end of the title for the page.

What am I missing here?

http://www.huntersfriendresort.com/